Chapter 3: Exempt is not the Same as naffected

3 min read

Book cover of Who Absorbs the Risk

This post is a summary of Chapter 3 of my soon to be released book – Who Absorbs the Risk. You can read the introduction here and learn a bit more about this project – https://rhislop3.com/who-absorbs-the-risk-a-40-year-journey/

Medicare taught me how Washington designs payment. Medicaid taught me how states spend money they don’t have.

In 2017 I called Medicaid the 800-pound gorilla of the skilled nursing business. My point was that no single headwind, not Medicare Advantage discounts, new regulations or rising labor costs, did as much damage as a high Medicaid share in a building’s payer mix. The federal government has since confirmed the math. Its 2024 study found that Medicaid pays nursing homes about 82 cents on the dollar, an average of $198 a day against $253 in cost.

Then, on July 4, 2025, Congress cut projected federal Medicaid spending by about $911 billion over ten years. The nursing home sector came out of the fight with real wins. Nursing facility provider taxes were exempted from the phase-down that will cut hospital taxes in expansion states. Work requirements apply to working-age adults, not to the residents in our beds. Those wins were earned through hard advocacy, and I don’t discount them.

But exempt isn’t the same as unaffected. The law freezes every provider tax in place, including ours. For a decade, the most common way for a state to fund a nursing home rate increase was to raise the bed tax toward the 6 percent ceiling and draw down the federal match. That tool is gone. Hospital taxes in 31 expansion states will shrink, and that revenue was freeing up general fund dollars for the rest of Medicaid. State-directed payments are capped. And every state now carries the administrative cost of work requirements and six-month renewals while its own revenue growth slows.

I’ve lived through enough Medicaid squeezes to know where that ends. States cut provider rates last, but they always get there. A nursing home’s exposure was never going to be written into the federal statute. It will be written into fifty state budgets over the next five years.

One provision doesn’t wait for the budgets. On January 1, 2027, retroactive coverage for most nursing home applicants drops from three months to two. A slow application stops being a cash-flow problem and becomes a write-off: about $5,900 per lost month at the average Medicaid rate. The fix is mostly discipline. Screen at admission, file early, and track every pending application weekly.

Chapter 3 of Who Absorbs the Risk walks through the law provision by provision, the history of every Medicaid squeeze since the Boren Amendment, and a state-by-state exposure matrix. It closes with what operators, boards and investors should do now, while there is still time.

For more including early access to the first printing go to https://whoabsorbstherisk.com

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Picture of Reg

Reg

Healthcare executive, consultant, and author covering post-acute care, senior living, and the economics behind both - for 30+ years.

Join Our Mailing List

No noise - just what changed in healthcare policy and economics, and why it matters to your operation.