
This post is a summary of Chapter 1 of my soon to be released book – Who Absorbs the Risk. You can read the introduction here and learn a bit more about this project – https://rhislop3.com/who-absorbs-the-risk-a-40-year-journey/
When people talk about the growth of Medicare Advantage, they usually describe it as a change in who administers Medicare. I think that misses the point. Medicare Advantage is a transfer of risk, and in post-acute care the transfer often ends at the provider.
The mechanics are simple. Medicare pays a plan a fixed amount per enrollee and steps back. From then on, every dollar the plan doesn’t spend on care is margin. The plan sits on both sides of that transaction. It is paid more when its members look sicker on paper, and it keeps more when it authorizes less care.
Both sides are now well documented. On the revenue side, investigators and the Justice Department have spent the last two years putting numbers on diagnoses that were added to records but never treated. On the payment side, the federal government’s June 2026 review of the 19 largest plans found that they denied about 12 percent of skilled nursing admission requests. Only 18 percent of those denials were appealed, and the plans reversed 95 percent of the ones that were. When a reversal rate is that high, initial denial looks like the default.
For skilled nursing operators, the effect shows up in the census. A Medicare Advantage stay runs far shorter than a traditional Medicare stay, so it takes roughly 1.6 Medicare Advantage admissions to replace one traditional Medicare admission. Each of those comes with an authorization, a concurrent review and often a peer-to-peer call. The rates are lower too. And traditional Medicare was never just another payer; it was the cross-subsidy that kept the Medicaid long-stay business solvent.
In Chapter 1 of Who Absorbs the Risk, I walk through how risk adjustment and prior authorization really work. I cover what the utilization research does and doesn’t show, and why the largest plans pulled out of hundreds of counties in 2026 and 2027. The chapter ends with practical guidance for operators, boards and investors. Medicare Advantage is the program now. The question is whether your organization is built to be paid by it.